What If?

Seven Retellings of “The Boy Who Cried Wolf”

This reimagining of The Boy Who Cried Wolf transforms one of literature’s oldest cautionary tales into a study of voice, tone, and perspective. By retelling the same story through the distinct styles of authors and figures as varied as Charles Dickens, Agatha Christie, Edgar Allan Poe, and even Nick Saban, students can see how diction, pacing, structure, and attitude completely reshape meaning. From Gothic dread to locker-room intensity, each version reveals the storyteller’s influence on how a reader feels and interprets the same series of events. A creative exercise in both reading and writing, this project encourages students to analyze authorial choices—and to experiment with finding a voice of their own.

Note to Teachers:

In your classroom, there are several ways to make use of this piece. You might read it aloud or have students read the stories silently, then discuss how style and tone change the message. Use it as a bridge into writing—inviting students to craft a fable in their own style or to identify which “author” matches each version without being told. However it’s approached, the exercise opens the door for deeper conversations about storytelling, perspective, and the power of voice.

Traditional Version

There once was a young shepherd boy who was hired to watch over a flock of sheep near a small village. He had little to do during the day except sit and watch the hillside. After several long and unexciting afternoons, the boy began to grow restless.

One day, just to amuse himself, he cried out, “Wolf! Wolf! A wolf is chasing the sheep!”

The villagers came running, climbing the hill with sticks in hand, ready to protect the flock. But when they arrived, they found no wolf—only the boy, laughing at the trick he had played.

The villagers scolded him and warned, “Do not lie! If you cry wolf again when there is none, no one will believe you next time.”

But the boy found it funny, and a few days later, he did it again.

“Wolf! Wolf!” he shouted.
 Once again, the villagers rushed up the hill—only to be fooled a second time. They were angry, and this time they left him with even sterner words.

Then, one evening, as the sun was setting behind the hills, a real wolf crept from the woods and began to stalk the sheep.

Frightened, the boy shouted with all his might, “Wolf! Wolf! Please help!”

But this time, the villagers thought he was lying again, and no one came.

The wolf scattered the flock—and ate the shepherd boy.

Moral:
 No one believes a liar—even when he tells the truth.

As Charles DickensMight Have Written It…

Richly descriptive, morally conscious, and emotionally layered style — complete with period voice, social observation, and Dickensian gravity…

Average Expectations

As Agatha Christie Might Have Written It...

With clever suspense, polished dialogue, and the keen psychological insight of a mystery set in a quiet English village where nothing is quite as simple as it seems.

The Case of the Vanishing Shepherd

As Dave Ramsey Might Have Told It...

In his sharp, no-nonsense, tough-love tone — part financial coach, part moral mentor — delivering timeless truth about credibility and personal responsibility.

The Boy with Irresponsible Parents

As Edgar Allan Poe Might Have Written It...

In a haunting, lyrical, and gothic style — where every whisper is a warning and even a simple fable trembles with dread, madness, and moral consequence.

The Boy and the Beast

As Coach Nick SabanMight Have Delivered It...

In a fiery, disciplined locker-room talk — a lesson in trust, focus, and execution told with the intensity of a championship at stake.

The Wolf That Will Steal Your National Championship

As Geoffrey Chaucer Myght Have Wryttn It...

In that olde, half-legible Englysh that maketh 8th grade students weep — full of strange spellings, rolling rhymes, and whatever it was that made their teachers think he was so grete.

The Tale of the Shepherde’s Boye and the Wulf

As President Donald Trump Might Have Told It...

In his unmistakable, unscripted style — bold, humorous, and full of exaggeration, repetition, and commentary that turns a fable into a rally speech.

Not A Great Guy…Who Cried Wolf

Discussion Questions:

1) How does each author’s unique voice change your emotional response to the same story? Which version felt most believable—or least believable—and why?

2) In what ways do diction, sentence structure, and tone reveal the storyteller’s personality or worldview?

3) If you were to retell The Boy Who Cried Wolf in your own voice, what would change first: the language, the setting, or the moral—and what would that reveal about your style as a writer?

Writers

Join the Conversation

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Loading...
View Cart Checkout Continue Shopping

Average Expectations

In a humble village of some obscurity—though not without its charm, nor lacking its share of mischief—there lived a boy employed in the rustic occupation of tending sheep. He was not a wicked boy, but one whose imagination exceeded his wisdom, and whose tongue oft outran the better judgment that time and experience have not yet had the occasion to instill.

Each morning he rose, not from a grand bedchamber but a simple cot, to accompany his charge to the hillsides beyond the town. There he watched, and waited, and longed for diversion. For the boy, like many lads of his constitution, found the honest labour of patience a burden too weighty for his restless spirit.

And so, one cloudless day, seeking sport and laughter, he did raise a most alarming cry: “Wolf! Wolf! A terrible beast among the flock!”

The townspeople—good-hearted and stout of character—dropped their labours, seized their walking sticks, and hastened uphill, spurred by loyalty to the flock and compassion for the boy. Upon arrival, they discovered no wolf, no danger, but only the lad in stitches of boyish glee.

Their faces, flushed with exertion and embarrassment, wore the frowns of men and women betrayed. One elder, stern of brow and voice like rusted hinges, warned him: “Falsity, young sir, is a weighty debt; it shall be paid in coin most dear.”

But alas, boys are oft slow to learn what life teaches best through sorrow. In mere days, the prank was played anew. Again he cried, “Wolf!” Again the village ran. Again they were made fools.

And so it was, when the real peril came—as perils do in their season—the wolf came not with drama, but hunger. A lean and cunning thing, whose yellow eyes glowed with the desperation of the famished. It slipped from the woods like shadow upon shadow and descended upon the field.

The boy saw it, and fear—no longer playful—gripped him. He screamed again, “Wolf! Wolf!” and this time with tears, not laughter.

But no one came.

The villagers, having been twice deceived, stayed at their tasks. Some shook their heads, others muttered of the boy’s character, but none climbed the hill.

And so the wolf—finding no resistance and no rescue—scattered the sheep like dry leaves in a gale...

...and devoured the shepherd boy himself.

Let this tale serve as testament to all who think truth a toy and trust a trifling matter—for when trust is spent, and truth lies buried beneath the ruins of jest, even the innocent cries of the guilty fall upon deaf ears.

The Case of the Vanishing Shepherd

A Rural Incident as Recounted by Inspector Poirot?)

It was a curious business altogether—one of those little events that might easily go unnoticed in a sleepy countryside, if not for the peculiar final result.

The boy was new to the village, a wiry lad with quick eyes and quicker words, hired to watch the flock that grazed on the upper slopes above Little Whitcombe. Nothing unusual there. Shepherding is dull work, and boys are known to make their own amusement. But this particular boy—let us call him Peter—had a flair for the dramatic.

One afternoon, quite out of nowhere, Peter came dashing into the village square. Breathless, wild-eyed, the whole scene was very theatrical.

“A wolf!” he gasped. “There’s a wolf among the sheep!”

Naturally, several of the more energetic gentlemen—including the retired Colonel from Rosebriar Lane and the vicar’s young nephew—armed themselves and set off with alacrity. But alas, no wolf. No tracks. Not so much as a tuft of fur. Only the boy, grinning slyly.

The matter might have been dismissed as youthful mischief—if it hadn’t happened again.

This time, more dramatically: “It nearly bit me!” he cried. “Its eyes were like coals, and it growled!”

Again the villagers responded. Again they found nothing. But the smiles were thinner now, and more than one person muttered darkly about “a boy who lies.”

And then came the third occasion. But this time, things were... different.

The boy didn’t come running. He didn’t come at all.

What they did find, hours later, was a scene of disorder: sheep scattered, blood on the grass, and no sign of the boy save his walking stick—snapped clean in two.

Inspector Poirot, observing from the edge of the pasture, simply shook his head.

“People assume lies are harmless,” he said, more to himself than anyone else. “But lies are like debts. They compound. And when the truth finally comes calling… no one answers.”

 

Epilogue (as if noted in Poirot’s diary):
 "The villagers were suspicious, mais oui. But they were also logical. A boy who lied twice might lie again. Yet it is the tragedy of human nature that a truth delayed is often a truth unheard. And so, the wolf had its supper."

The Boy With Irresponsible Parents

All right, folks—gather around. This one’s a classic. It’s not about money, but it’s about character, and if you don’t have that, then I don’t care how much you make—you’re broke where it counts.

So here’s the deal:

There’s this young guy—probably thinks he’s clever. His job is to watch sheep. That’s his role. Not glamorous. Not exciting. But it matters. Somebody gave him that responsibility and trusted him with it.

Well, he gets bored. So he starts crying, “Wolf! Wolf!”—just to stir people up. No wolf. Just drama. And the villagers? Good people—they show up. They run up the hill, ready to help. That’s called community, by the way. That's what happens when people still believe in each other.

But the kid laughs. Total disrespect. He pulls the same stunt again. And again.

Now let me stop right there and ask you this: How many people in your life have “cried wolf” so many times that when real trouble hits, no one listens anymore?

That’s not a people problem—that’s a you problem.
 That’s what happens when you spend your credibility like it’s Monopoly money. Eventually, you're out—and when you really need it? It’s gone.

So back to the story:
 The wolf finally shows up. Real deal. Teeth, claws, the whole package. The boy screams. “Help! Wolf! Please!”
 And this time?
 Nobody comes.
And yes—he loses the sheep.
 And the wolf eats him.
 Brutal? Yep. But truth doesn't care about your feelings.

So what’s the Lesson?

You want to build wealth? You want healthy relationships? Don’t cry wolf.

Credibility is like money:
You earn it slowly, you can lose it fast, and if you're stupid with it, no one bails you out.

Now get to work.
And if you’re the one crying wolf—knock it off. 

You’re better than that.

The Boy and the Beast…A Caution Most Macabre

Once—in a vale of desolation where fog clung like sorrow upon the hills—there lived a boy whose mind was light, but whose voice, alas, carried farther than his truth.

He was a shepherd, tasked with the care of meek beasts who bleated beneath a pale and trembling moon. His days were long, and the silence—Oh! the silence!—gnawed at him like invisible vermin. In that yawning stillness of meadow and thought, he conceived a jest. A cruel, boyish jest. A cry of terror when there was none.

“Wolf!” he shrieked, and the echoes fled in all directions like panicked ghosts. The townsfolk, decent and harried, came thundering through the mist—faces aghast, eyes wide with dread. But there was no wolf. Only laughter. Hollow, mirthless, echoing.

They warned him. Yes—they warned him with words etched in the stone of human experience:

"He who lies shall not be believed—when most he is in need."

Yet—O, horror!—he did it again.

“Wolf!” he cried a second time, and again they came. But the seed of distrust had been sown, and their brows were not as furrowed, their strides not as swift. This time, they left with eyes that no longer saw him—but looked through him, as through the specter of a child not yet dead, but doomed.

Then came the night.

A true night. The kind that drinks light from the stars. A howl rose from the wood—not from the boy’s throat, but from the cursed throat of the Beast. Not mere wolf, no. A terror older than tales. Its fur was shadow, and its breath, frost.

He cried out—"Wolf! O God, help! Wolf!"—but the town slept, or turned in their beds, or whispered, “He lies.”

They did not come.

And so the Beast came instead.

It scattered the sheep with ease.
 It found the boy.
 It looked upon him with ancient eyes.
 And it knew.

He fled. He pleaded. He wept.

And the Beast devoured him.

Not with hunger—but with judgment.

The Moral (if such things survive the dark):

He who toys with terror shall one day find it real.

The Wolf That Will Steal Your National Championship

All right, listen up.

You ever hear the story about the boy who cried wolf?

I know it sounds like a kindergarten thing, but pay attention, ah-ite?  Because it’s exactly what happens to teams that don't understand the value of credibility. That don’t understand trust.

This kid—he had a job. Simple job. Protect the flock. Be where you're supposed to be. Do what you're supposed to do. But he lost focus. He got cute. Wanted attention. So what did he do?

He starts yelling: “Wolf! Wolf!” even when there was no wolf.  Ah-ite?

And the people? They come runnin’. First time. Second time. They're trying to help. Just like your coaches trying to get you to do it the right way. Just like your teammates believing you're gonna be where you’re supposed to be—trusting that when it’s 3rd and long, you’ve got their back.

But that kid? He lied. Played around. Thought he was bigger than the moment.

And then the wolf actually shows up.

He screams again. “Wolf! Wolf!”
 But this time?
 Nobody comes.

Why?

Because when you lose trust, it doesn’t come back when you need it.
 Because when you spend all your time talking and not doing, you don’t get a second shot in the fourth quarter.
 Because when the game gets real, it’s too late to start doing the right thing.

That boy? The wolf eats him.
 And nobody even blinks.

Now here’s the deal, fellas:

I’m seeing a lot of you crying wolf out there—pointin' fingers—but not executing, ah-ite?

You say you’re ready. You say you care. But do your actions match your words?

Because if we go back out there and you blow your assignments, or you freelance, or you take a down off—don’t be surprised when the wolf shows up and blows right through this team.

The wolf doesn’t care about your talent.
The wolf doesn’t care about how many stars you had in high school or your NIL valuation now.
The wolf shows up every single play—and the only thing that will save your butt is discipline, accountability, and earning trust every down.

So what’s it gonna be?

You wanna cry wolf and hope it works out?
Or you wanna go back out there, play the right way, and beat the wolf to the punch?

So, let’s go, ah-ite?  Eyes up. Lock in.
Be where you’re supposed to be. Do your job.

The Tale of the Shepherde’s Boye and the Wulf

Whilom, as clerkès write in bookès olde,
 Ther was a lad, ful rakish, blythe and bolde.
 A shepherde’s boye he was, with crook in hande,
 That kepte his sheep upon a pleasant lande.

The morwe was fayre, the lambès fed ful still,
 Yet idle thoughts doth often breedeth ill.
 This boye, y-wearied of his quiet charge,
 Gan think to make a jest bothe loud and large.

“Ho! Wulf! A wulf!” quoth he, with wondrous cry,
 And villagèrs cam running hastily—
 With staves and stones and cryès rude and sharp,
 As if to drive the beast into the dark.

But when they saw no beast, ne blood, ne fraye,
 The boye he laughed, and bade them “Go thy waye!”
 Thus was he warnèd, though he took no heed—
 For flattery and jest are falsè seed.

Yet twyes more did he the same disport,
 And echè time the folk cam in report.
 But by the thirde, their trust was turned to ire,
 And they returnèd home with naught but fire.

Now falleth it upon a murkè night
 That out of wood there cam a shape of fright—
 A wulf, with eyen glimmering like the coals,
 That haunteth sheep and seeketh wayward soules.

The boye, in dread, y-cleped loud and long:
 “Ho! Wulf! A wulf! O help me, or I’m gone!”
 But none there came, for no man would believe—
 They deemed it jest, and left him there to grieve.

The beast he sprang, with hunger in his bone,
 And all was still, save one last mufflèd groan.

Moralitas (as Chaucer would end it):

Who maketh mock of feare and truth defyeth,
 Shall fynde no helpe when real peryl nigh’eth.

Not A Great Guy…Who Cried Wolf

There was a boy—a young guy, not too bright, frankly—but he was in charge of the sheep. A lot of sheep. Some people said it was the best flock they’d ever seen. I don’t know. I’ve seen better. But it was decent. And he had one job. Just one. Watch the sheep. Keep them safe.

Now, he gets tired. Like a lot of people who don’t want to work—he gets tired.  And what does he do? He starts crying, “Wolf! Wolf!” He’s making it up. It’s fake. Fake news. Complete hoax. And the people—they come running! Good people, by the way. Hardworking. They show up. They care.

And guess what? No wolf. Nothing. Total setup.

He does it again. Same thing. “Wolf! Wolf!”—no wolf. He thinks it's funny. Maybe he wants attention. Maybe he wants a book deal. Who knows?

But then—then—one day, the real wolf shows up. And it’s not a nice wolf, believe me. It’s not one of these friendly, liberal wolves you hear about. It’s a tremendous wolf. Very dangerous. Very hungry.

So the boy cries again. “Wolf! Wolf!” He’s yelling. He’s screaming. It’s a disaster. But guess what? Nobody shows up. Nobody believes him. They say, “We’ve heard this before. It’s a total scam.”

And the wolf?
 He eats the sheep.
 He eats the boy.
 Total destruction. Worst ending you’ve ever seen.

Very sad. Could’ve been avoided. Wouldn’t have happened under my watch. I’m just saying.